Yes — on almost every pocket diamond tester, a moissanite lights up exactly like a diamond. That is a limit of the instrument, not proof of the stone. The FTC documents it in its trade guidance, and has for years.
Every week someone writes to us with the same story: they took their new iced-out piece to a jeweler, the jeweler touched a pen to the stones, and the pen said “diamond.” Great news — except the piece is moissanite, and now the buyer does not know what they own. Nothing was faked. The pen did exactly what a pen does. So let's settle it properly, with the sources in the open.
There are two families of handheld tester, and the difference between them is the whole story:
Neither reading tells you anything about how a stone looks. A tester measures physics, not beauty.
Moissanite is silicon carbide (SiC). It is its own material: refractive index 2.65–2.69, dispersion 0.104, Mohs hardness 9.25, birefringence 0.043. Not a copy of diamond, not a variety of it, and not carbon.
One of those properties happens to be very high heat conductivity — close enough to diamond's that a pen built to catch cubic zirconia cannot tell the two apart. The FTC puts it in plain language in In the Loupe: Advertising Diamond, Gemstones and Pearls: “Thermal testers used to distinguish diamonds from cubic zirconia may not accurately identify moissanite — a laboratory-created gemstone that resembles a diamond. As a result, this stone may falsely register as a diamond on your thermal detector.” The same guidance then tells the trade to use a newer instrument, or another method, to separate them.
Read that carefully, because it is also the honest reading of a phrase you see all over iced-out jewelry: passes a diamond tester is a real quality signal — it means the stones are not cheap CZ — but it is not a claim that the stone is a diamond. A seller who tells you a passing tester makes the piece “diamond” is making a different and much larger statement. (The material itself, properly explained, is in What Is Moissanite? The Complete 2026 Guide.)
| Method | What you read | What it can tell you | What it cannot tell you |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Single thermal pen (one step, heat only) | A heat-conductivity reading, usually shown as diamond / other, sometimes with a colour bar. | Whether the stone conducts heat like a diamond or poorly like cubic zirconia or glass. Catching CZ is what this tool was built for. | Diamond from moissanite. Silicon carbide conducts heat closely enough to diamond that the pen reads both the same — the exact limitation the FTC documents. |
| 2. Two-step multi-tester (heat, then electrical conductivity) | Two readings in sequence: thermal first, then resistance to a small current. | This is the pair that separates the two materials. Silicon carbide conducts electricity; most diamonds do not. A thermal pass plus a conductive second step reads as moissanite. | Any grade at all. It names a material, not a quality — nothing about colour, clarity, cut, or the metal under the stones. |
| 3. 10× loupe, facet-edge doubling | Whether the facet edges below the table look single or doubled. | Moissanite is doubly refractive (birefringence 0.043), so its edges double under magnification. Diamond is singly refractive and stays clean and single. It works on a mounted stone. | A material name on its own, and it needs a clean table and a trained eye. Treat it as confirmation, not as a first opinion. |
Sources: FTC, In the Loupe (trade guidance on diamond testers and moissanite); Presidium Instruments, product documentation for its multi tester; published gemological reference data for silicon carbide. The same three materials side by side are in Moissanite vs CZ vs Lab Diamond (2026).
Three solitaires of the same stone material in three sizes: a white-metal four-prong, a gold-tone four-prong and a white-metal six-prong. Size and setting change the price and the presence; neither changes what the instrument reads. The clip below shows a tester being run over a graduated three-pendant set, from the smallest stone to the largest.
Cheap testers are useful, and they are widely misused. In a National Jeweler feature sponsored by the International Gemological Institute, the lab warned that “an alarming number of pros continue to mistakenly believe that inexpensive diamond testers will distinguish” natural diamonds from lab-grown ones — and the same over-trust is what makes a moissanite read as “diamond” to a buyer. That is why laboratories still screen goods with spectrometric analysis rather than a pen off a bench.
A single reading from a single pen is a screening result. It is not an identification, and anyone who presents it as one — in either direction — is guessing with confidence.
Three checks do the work, in this order:
That is why, when we describe a stone's colour or clarity, we attribute it to our supply standard — D–F colour, VVS clarity, excellent cut — and not to a grade. The paperwork that ships with a piece with a centre stone over 1 carat is a Certificate of Authenticity confirming the stone is moissanite, not a grading certificate. If you are buying anywhere else, ask which of the two you are being handed.
A tester question is usually a buying question in disguise: what am I paying for, and would I know if I had been sold something else. Here are five pieces from the current catalogue with the number you actually pay — no invented ranges, no membership games.
| Piece | Metal | Stone | Price (USD) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oval 8ct cocktail ring, fully iced NOV-RG-1020 | 925 sterling silver | Moissanite, oval cut | $544 | View ring |
| Praying Hands hoop earrings NOV-EA-1004 | 925 sterling silver (gold-tone and rose-tone: 18K gold plated) | Moissanite, pavé-set | $149 | View earrings |
| Thorn Rose heart pendant NOV-PD-1015 | 925 sterling silver (colour variants are plated) | Moissanite, pavé-set | $619 | View pendant |
| Four-prong solitaire pendant chain NOV-CH-9854 | 925 sterling silver | Moissanite solitaire | $119 / $139 / $169 / $209 1ct / 2ct / 3ct / 5ct | View chain |
| Four-prong 3.5ct solitaire ring NOV-RG-1041 | 925 sterling silver | Moissanite solitaire | $139 | View ring |
Prices are our own catalogue prices as of October 2026, in USD, and vary with the carat weight or size you choose. Per-piece cost breakdowns: moissanite rings, tennis bracelets, Cuban chains.
Does moissanite pass a diamond tester?
On almost every pocket thermal tester, yes. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission states that thermal testers used to distinguish diamond from cubic zirconia may not accurately identify moissanite, and that the stone may falsely register as a diamond on a thermal detector. That is a documented limitation of the instrument, not proof that the stone is a diamond.
If a stone fails a diamond tester, is it cubic zirconia?
Usually, yes. Cubic zirconia is a poor conductor of heat, so it reads low or gives no reading on a working thermal tester, while moissanite is highly conductive of heat and almost never fails one. A stone that fails is far more likely CZ or glass than moissanite.
How does a jeweler actually tell moissanite from diamond?
Three checks. Under a 10× loupe, moissanite is doubly refractive, so facet edges below the table appear doubled while diamond shows single edges. On a two-step multi-tester, the electrical-conductivity reading separates silicon carbide from most diamonds. And paperwork from a laboratory names the material rather than grading it on the diamond scale.
Does testing damage the stone or the setting?
No. Testers work by contact probe, reading heat or electrical conductivity. There is no radiation, no scratching and nothing left behind on the piece.
Is moissanite graded like a diamond?
No. Moissanite is not graded on the diamond clarity scale; GIA has put the point exactly, describing a moissanite's clarity as what it would have been equivalent to if such grades were assigned to synthetic moissanite — which they are not. When we publish a colour and clarity standard, that is our own supply standard for the stones we buy, not a laboratory grade.
What paperwork should come with a moissanite piece?
A Certificate of Authenticity that names the material — moissanite — is the honest document, and on our pieces it ships with any centre stone over 1 carat, issued against our own stone standard. Separately, IGI began issuing its own Certificates of Authenticity for moissanite on 16 December 2022, with Dallas-based distributor Roseco, confirming the material and recording the stone's shape and weight. A document that grades a moissanite on the diamond clarity scale is a record of a supplier's standard, not of the material — GIA assigns no clarity grade to moissanite at all.
Send a photo of what you have in mind — a chain, a tennis bracelet, an iced watch — and we will tell you the stone option, the metal and the actual price before you commit. If you already own a piece from us and want to know exactly what is in it, ask and we will confirm the material on your order.
Ask on WhatsAppSources: U.S. Federal Trade Commission, In the Loupe: Advertising Diamond, Gemstones and Pearls, section on diamond testers and moissanite; Presidium Instruments, product documentation for its diamond/moissanite multi tester (thermal and electrical readings); International Gemological Institute, Certificates of Authenticity for moissanite, 16 December 2022; National Jeweler, feature on gem screening sponsored by IGI; GIA, Gems & Gemology lab note on synthetic moissanite with a fraudulent GIA inscription (Fall 2020) and lab note on clarity grades for synthetic moissanite; published gemological reference data for silicon carbide (refractive index 2.65–2.69, dispersion 0.104, Mohs hardness 9.25, birefringence 0.043). Prices in the table above are our own catalogue prices as of October 2026, in USD, and vary with the carat weight or size you choose. Stone testers are screening instruments; for a legal or insurance-grade identification, use a gemological laboratory. More background in the NOVAE blog.
Made to order in our Guangzhou atelier — 925 sterling silver, hand-set moissanite.
Everything here is made and set on our own bench in Guangzhou — 925 sterling silver and moissanite, with gold-tone plated alloy watch cases where the listing says so. If you are buying for a store, a brand or a reseller, the wholesale pages carry the minimums, lead times and terms:
Retail pieces in the same workshop: 16mm Cuban link chain · 18mm iced Cuban chain · RAM iced out pendant · Iced out square-case watch