Short answer: a 925 silver necklace turns black because of silver sulfide, not dirt. Check whether yours is plated before you clean it: abrasive pastes take the plating off, and the silver underneath then blackens faster.
Most guides start with a toothbrush and toothpaste. That order is backwards: on a plated necklace the usual remedies strip the finish before they reach the tarnish.
The black is silver sulfide, Ag2S. Silver meets hydrogen sulfide in the air — the gas behind a rotten egg, present almost everywhere at low levels and higher near rubber, wool and heavy traffic — and the two react at the surface. What forms sits on the metal, not in it: detergent will not shift it.
Sterling is 92.5% silver and 7.5% copper; the copper gives the alloy its hardness and reacts first, forming copper sulfide, Cu2S, alongside the silver sulfide. That is why 925 darkens faster than fine silver — not a sign of a lower grade.
Humidity is the multiplier: the Canadian Conservation Institute puts storage below 50% relative humidity, because the reaction needs moisture. Weeks in a damp bathroom drawer; a year when the piece is wiped and bagged. And it starts where air and skin both reach: the back of the neck, the clasp.
Before any method, look at the surface. Almost every silver chain is one of three constructions.
That decides the method, because every household abrasive works by grinding. Toothpaste, baking soda paste and jeweller’s rouge take the sulfide off by taking the surface with it — a trace of metal on bare silver, the whole plating on a plated piece, and once that is gone the exposed silver darkens faster than the finish did.
Unsure? Read the worn points: a plated piece shows a paler patch at the clasp, not a darker one. How each finish ages is in Does Moissanite Tarnish? It’s the Metal, Not the Stone.
The first step is a cloth, and it is enough more often than people expect: fold a soft dry microfibre and pull the chain through it in one direction.
It takes off the faint yellow film, drawer dullness and handling marks. It does not take off black that has sat for months, or black between links.
Stop when the cloth stops coming away grey. If it is clean and the piece is still dark you have hit the limit: thicker film, a gap a cloth cannot reach, or plating wear. Rubbing harder only scratches the metal, and a scratched surface holds the next film.
This is the step most people skip, and it fixes what looks exactly like tarnish and is not: skin oil, cream, sunscreen and soap packed into the gaps.
On textured pieces it is the only step that reaches the problem: the thorn-cut links are where cream collects. It does not remove silver sulfide, though — if the piece dries black, the problem is chemical.
The foil method sounds like folklore and is not: it puts the silver back rather than taking the surface off.
3Ag2S + 2Al → 6Ag + Al2S3. Aluminium is more reactive than silver, so in a baking soda solution it gives up electrons, the silver sulfide takes them, the silver returns to metal and the sulfide binds to the aluminium — reduction, not dissolution, at no cost in metal.
Not for: plated pieces, where there is no sulfide on the coating to reduce; glued stones and pearls; any piece whose black you cannot identify — test a cotton bud under the clasp first.
Use the lowest level that works.
| Level | For | What you do | Time | Plating | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Dry cloth | Faint film, dulling | Pull the chain through a soft dry cloth, one direction | 2–3 min | None if untreated | Low; scratches over grit |
| 2. Wash | Oil and cream in gaps | Lukewarm water, dish soap, soft brush, rinse in a bowl | 5–10 min | None | Low; lost down the drain |
| 3. Foil bath | Thick sulfide, bare silver | Foil-lined bowl, baking soda, hot water, piece on the foil | about 10 min | Not for plated | Moderate; plating edge, glued settings |
None of the three restores a worn plating layer; if the black is a thinned patch at the clasp, the fix is a re-plate, not a clean.
Tarnish is not preventable forever. It is slowable, and most of the slowing is storage.
Pricing is in the Cuban chain cost guide, the tennis bracelet cost guide and the pendant cost guide. To check a stone yourself, the three home checks.
Silver sulfide, not dirt. Silver reacts with hydrogen sulfide in the air, and the 7.5% copper in a 925 alloy forms copper sulfide alongside it — which is why sterling darkens faster than fine silver. Humidity speeds it up.
You can, and on a plated piece you should not. Toothpaste cleans by abrasion, so it takes the plating off with the sulfide, and on bare silver it leaves scratches that hold the next film.
Yes, on bare silver: the aluminium gives electrons to the silver sulfide, the silver returns to metal and the sulfide binds to the aluminium. No metal is ground away. It does not fix plating wear.
Not the water-and-soap step, and yes to anything abrasive. Toothpaste, baking soda paste, polishing compound and silver dip all attack a plated layer; a soft cloth and a soft brush do not.
Dry, sealed, dark and away from sulfur: under 50% relative humidity in a zip bag with a silica sachet, off before showers and pools, a dry wipe after a hot day. 925 silver tarnishes eventually.
Send a daylight photo of the dark area, silver-tone or gold-tone, and we will say whether it needs a cloth, a wash, the foil bath or a re-plate.
اسأل على واتسابSources: Canadian Conservation Institute, Understanding how silver objects tarnish (silver sulfide formation, hydrogen sulfide, 50% relative humidity) — canada.ca; Sheffield Assay Office, Why does silver tarnish? (copper in the 925 alloy, sulfur sources) — assayoffice.co.uk; Silver to Black — and Back, Journal of Chemical Education 77(3), 2000 (aluminium reduction of silver sulfide) — pubs.acs.org. Prices: our own catalogue variant prices, 4 November 2026, in USD.
Made to order in our Guangzhou atelier — 925 sterling silver, hand-set moissanite.
The tennis chain is bare polished 925 silver; the three Cuban links are rhodium-plated over the same silver. Either way the metal underneath is silver, and the coating only delays tarnish. How moissanite compares with cubic zirconia: the material comparison.
Everything here is made and set on our own bench in Guangzhou — 925 sterling silver and moissanite, with gold-tone plated alloy watch cases where the listing says so. If you are buying for a store, a brand or a reseller, the wholesale pages carry the minimums, lead times and terms:
Retail pieces in the same workshop: 16mm Cuban link chain · 18mm iced Cuban chain · RAM iced out pendant · Iced out square-case watch